A best waterproof mascara should be reliable, if nothing else. While some mascara can result in smudgy raccoon eyes and dramatic mascara tears, the right formula will stand up against the elements, allergy season, ugly crying, and everything in between. Whatever the day throws at you, the right waterproof mascara should keep your lashes looking pristine no matter what.
Read Also: Best Anti Aging Serum for Wrinkles
Is waterproof mascara better than regular mascara?
In some cases, yes. Waterproof mascaras are typically superior in keeping lashes lifted and curled. They are usually a bit stickier, may clump during the application process, and require more time to dry. Once set, they usually do not smudge yet may be prone to flaking.
You need to be careful when removing it to avoid irritating your eyes and pulling at your lashes. Since waterproof mascaras require harsher removal conditions, this can cause lashes to fall out or irritate the skin around the eyes.
Below are the best waterproof mascaras to survive sweaty days, teary nights, and more:
BEST VALUE WATERPROOF MASCARA
1. LashBlast Volume Waterproof Mascara
This pick is a cult classic for great reason: It was so impressive that it earned the GH Seal. The formula went on smoothly, added lots of volume, and lengthened without flaking or smudging. This brush was the easiest to use, and the formula also snagged perfect scores for being non-irritating, even on super-sensitive eyes and skin.
It earned a perfect score for not running even when doused with water.
BEST NON-CLUMPING WATERPROOF MASCARA
2. Peacock Flare Waterproof Mascara
Prepare for feathery lashes, thanks to the unique helix shape on this rubber wand. This mascara earned the highest scores for resisting smudges, smears, and runs, and testers noted that it was non-irritating and with a pleasant scent, making it great for sensitive skin (and noses!).
The brush applicator was easy to use, but they needed a few coats to get their desired look, they would have like to see more volume. It’s also worth noting that the formula a little difficult to remove at the end of the day.
REVIEWER FAVORITE WATERPROOF MASCARA
3. Volum’ Express The Colossal Waterproof Mascara
The formula lasts longer than other mascaras without flaking, and that the wand does an excellent job coating and separating lashes with little to no clumping.
It’s also easy to use: Just one coat does the trick, and that it stays put no matter what. If you are looking for a mascara that will withstand a waterfall landing on your face … this is the one for you.
BEST WATER-RESISTANT MASCARA
4. They’re Real! Lengthening & Volumizing Mascara
If you hate tugging at your lashes to remove it, opt for this water-resistant pick: It’s not waterproof, but the budge-proof formula stands up to teary eyes and sweaty days much better than traditional non-waterproof formulas, without the hassle of removing a truly waterproof formula.
EXPERT FAVORITE WATERPROOF MASCARA
5. Total Temptation Waterproof Mascara
It goes on smoothly, dries fast, and stays put through humid days and allergy seasons without compromising the plush look of the lashes.